Salt water causes marine ecosystems to be very different from freshwater ecosystems. Organisms in both types of ecosystems are affected by the freezing and melting of ice. An experiment was conducted to test the hypothesis that ice melts faster in salt water than in fresh water. Ice cubes made of fresh water were placed into cups containing either fresh water or salt water. Various data were recorded, and the energy released by each melting ice cube was calculated from the data. The table shows the results for each cup.
What statement describes one or more needed changes to this experiment that would allow the experimenter to draw a valid conclusion?
- A. Salt water should have been used to make the ice cubes for the cup of salt water.
- B. The time for ice cubes to melt should have been measured in minutes.
- C. At the beginning, both cups should have contained the same mass of water at the same temperature.
- D. The energy released should have been measured, not calculated.
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: C
Option C highlights the necessity for both cups to start with the same mass of water at the same temperature to ensure a fair comparison. This control eliminates variables that could skew results, allowing for a valid conclusion about the melting rates of ice cubes in different solutions. Option A is incorrect because using salt water to make ice cubes would not provide relevant data on how the ice behaves in fresh versus salt water. Option B is not a change that affects the experimental validity; measuring time in minutes is appropriate, but the key is ensuring conditions are equal. Option D suggests a measurement method change, but calculating energy based on temperature changes is acceptable in this context.
Option C highlights the necessity for both cups to start with the same mass of water at the same temperature to ensure a fair comparison. This control eliminates variables that could skew results, allowing for a valid conclusion about the melting rates of ice cubes in different solutions. Option A is incorrect because using salt water to make ice cubes would not provide relevant data on how the ice behaves in fresh versus salt water. Option B is not a change that affects the experimental validity; measuring time in minutes is appropriate, but the key is ensuring conditions are equal. Option D suggests a measurement method change, but calculating energy based on temperature changes is acceptable in this context.
Other Related Questions
Which instruction would be most appropriate for step 2 of the procedure?
- A. Provide both group A and group B participants with a daily magnesium supplement.
- B. Provide group A participants with a daily magnesium supplement and provide group B participants with a daily supplement that contains only inactive ingredients.
- C. Provide group A participants with a high-magnesium supplement and group B participants with a low-magnesium supplement...
- D. Provide both group A and group B participants with guidelines about which foods they should consume.
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: B
Option B is the most appropriate instruction for step 2 as it establishes a clear experimental control. By giving group A a magnesium supplement and group B an inactive placebo, it allows for a direct comparison of the effects of magnesium on the participants. Option A is incorrect because it does not create a control group; both groups would receive magnesium, making it impossible to determine its specific effects. Option C is flawed as it introduces an additional variable by varying the magnesium levels between groups, complicating the results. Option D fails to provide a direct intervention, which is essential for assessing the impact of magnesium supplementation.
Option B is the most appropriate instruction for step 2 as it establishes a clear experimental control. By giving group A a magnesium supplement and group B an inactive placebo, it allows for a direct comparison of the effects of magnesium on the participants. Option A is incorrect because it does not create a control group; both groups would receive magnesium, making it impossible to determine its specific effects. Option C is flawed as it introduces an additional variable by varying the magnesium levels between groups, complicating the results. Option D fails to provide a direct intervention, which is essential for assessing the impact of magnesium supplementation.
Which hypothesis is suitable for this investigation?
- A. Body temperature, breathing rate, and heart rate depend on the health of the subject.
- B. Many of the body's systems respond to exercise.
- C. Body temperature, breathing rate, and heart rate increase with exercise.
- D. Subjects at rest have better health than subjects that exercise.
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: C
Option C effectively addresses the investigation by predicting a specific relationship: that body temperature, breathing rate, and heart rate will increase with exercise. This hypothesis is testable and directly relates to physiological responses during physical activity. Option A is too broad, as it suggests a general relationship between health and various physiological metrics without focusing on exercise. Option B, while relevant, lacks specificity regarding the measurable changes in body temperature, breathing rate, and heart rate. Option D presents a misleading comparison, as it contradicts established knowledge about the benefits of exercise for health.
Option C effectively addresses the investigation by predicting a specific relationship: that body temperature, breathing rate, and heart rate will increase with exercise. This hypothesis is testable and directly relates to physiological responses during physical activity. Option A is too broad, as it suggests a general relationship between health and various physiological metrics without focusing on exercise. Option B, while relevant, lacks specificity regarding the measurable changes in body temperature, breathing rate, and heart rate. Option D presents a misleading comparison, as it contradicts established knowledge about the benefits of exercise for health.
Placing solid ammonium nitrate, NH4NO3, in a container of water causes an endothermic reaction. The result is ammonium hydroxide, NH4OH, and nitric acid, HNO3. Which diagram shows the correct equation for the reaction?
- A. NH4OH + HNO3 → NH4NO3 + H2O + energy
- B. NH4NO3 + H2O + energy → NH4OH + HNO3
- C. NH4NO3 + H2O → NH4OH + HNO3 + energy
- D. NH4OH + HNO3 + energy → NH4NO3 + H2O
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: B
The reaction between solid ammonium nitrate and water is endothermic, meaning it absorbs energy. Thus, the equation must reflect the consumption of energy during the process. Option B correctly shows that ammonium nitrate (NH4NO3) and water react to form ammonium hydroxide (NH4OH) and nitric acid (HNO3), while requiring energy input. Option A incorrectly suggests energy is released, which contradicts the endothermic nature of the reaction. Option C implies that energy is produced, which is also incorrect. Option D similarly misrepresents the reaction by suggesting energy is released, aligning with an exothermic process rather than the observed endothermic reaction.
The reaction between solid ammonium nitrate and water is endothermic, meaning it absorbs energy. Thus, the equation must reflect the consumption of energy during the process. Option B correctly shows that ammonium nitrate (NH4NO3) and water react to form ammonium hydroxide (NH4OH) and nitric acid (HNO3), while requiring energy input. Option A incorrectly suggests energy is released, which contradicts the endothermic nature of the reaction. Option C implies that energy is produced, which is also incorrect. Option D similarly misrepresents the reaction by suggesting energy is released, aligning with an exothermic process rather than the observed endothermic reaction.
Scientists are Interested in whether certain greenhouse gases have helped cause I recent temperature increases. The graph presents data on carbon dioxide and methane gas levels in the atmosphere for the past several centuries. Human activities began producing large quantities of both gases in the 1700s. This graph, combined with information from--------------------, supports ----------------------.
- A. The Milankovitch climate change model
- B. paragraph 3
- C. The anthropogenic climate change model
- D. Paragraph 2
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: B, C
The graph illustrates the correlation between rising greenhouse gas levels and temperature increases, supporting the anthropogenic climate change model, which attributes climate change to human activities. Options B and C effectively connect the visual data with the broader context of human influence on climate. Option A, referencing the Milankovitch model, is incorrect as this model focuses on natural Earth cycles, not human impact. Option D lacks specificity and does not directly relate to the evidence presented in the graph. Thus, B and C provide the most relevant support for understanding the relationship between greenhouse gas emissions and climate change.
The graph illustrates the correlation between rising greenhouse gas levels and temperature increases, supporting the anthropogenic climate change model, which attributes climate change to human activities. Options B and C effectively connect the visual data with the broader context of human influence on climate. Option A, referencing the Milankovitch model, is incorrect as this model focuses on natural Earth cycles, not human impact. Option D lacks specificity and does not directly relate to the evidence presented in the graph. Thus, B and C provide the most relevant support for understanding the relationship between greenhouse gas emissions and climate change.