Scientists have examined the genetic history of a large group of cheetahs and have found that
there was a significant decrease in the genetic diversity of the cheetah species about 10,000 years
ago. Scientists found that, even in unrelated groups of cheetahs, individual cheetahs had 99% of
the same alleles. By comparison, in a genetically diverse population, even closely related
individuals contain only 80% of the same alleles. Genetic diversity is important to the survival of a
species, and scientists worry that a disease that cheetahs are not resistant to could decimate the
population.
Major histocompatibility complex (MC) genes are used by the body to identify self from non-self
and direct the immune system to attack non-self particles. Invading bacteria and viruses do not
contain the same MHC genes and therefore are attacked by the immune system. Within a
population, a high diversity of MHC genes protects the population from attack by disease. In a
highly diverse population, it is likely that at least some individuals will contain an allele that
identifies a new disease as non-self and can direct the immune system to destroy it.
In 1985, research by Stephen O'Brien reported that skin grafts from cheetahs in a zoo in Oregon
were accepted by cheetahs in Africa. Skin grafts, like other organ donations, must be between
Individuals that have the same MHC factors. If any of the genetic factors are different, then the
immune system of the individual receiving the organ will identify the organ as non-self and the
body will attack the donated organ as if it were a foreign organism such as a virus or bacterium.
The conclusion from
O'Brien's research was that cheetah MHC genes are as alike as those of identical twins.
More recent research by Simone Sommer took a much more comprehensive approach to
examining the genes of a large sample of wild cheetahs. Sommer's research determined how
many alleles are present on two different types of MHC genes in approximately 150 cheetahs.
Sommer was able to show that the variation in some MHC genes was higher than previously
thought. The variation in MHC genes in cheetahs is still smaller than that for other big cat species
but appears to be sufficient to allow the populations to identify a wide variety of foreign particles.
Why is the conclusion about gene variation among cheetahs from Sommer's research more valid than the conclusion from O'Brien's research?
- A. Sommer's research was conducted more recently than O'Brien's
- B. Sommer's research used a different population of cheetahs than O'Brien's
- C. Sommer's conclusion is about disease response, while O'Brien's is about skin grafts.
- D. Sommer's conclusion is based on examining the genes, while O'Brien's conclusion is based on acceptance of a skin graft.
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: D
Sommer's conclusion is more valid as it directly examines gene variation, providing a clearer understanding of genetic factors influencing traits. This direct analysis allows for more reliable insights into gene functionality. In contrast, O'Brien's research focuses on skin graft acceptance, which, while informative, does not provide the same depth of genetic examination. Option A is incorrect as recency does not inherently validate research findings. Option B is misleading; differing populations may affect findings but do not necessarily validate one conclusion over another. Option C misrepresents the focus of the studies; both are relevant but differ in application rather than validity.
Sommer's conclusion is more valid as it directly examines gene variation, providing a clearer understanding of genetic factors influencing traits. This direct analysis allows for more reliable insights into gene functionality. In contrast, O'Brien's research focuses on skin graft acceptance, which, while informative, does not provide the same depth of genetic examination. Option A is incorrect as recency does not inherently validate research findings. Option B is misleading; differing populations may affect findings but do not necessarily validate one conclusion over another. Option C misrepresents the focus of the studies; both are relevant but differ in application rather than validity.
Other Related Questions
The roller coaster diagram shows a set of cars moving downward from position 1 to position 2. As the cars travel from position 1 toward position 2, their...
- A. gravitational potential energy; total energy
- B. kinetic energy; gravitational potential energy
- C. total energy; kinetic energy
- D. gravitational potential energy; kinetic energy
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: A
As the roller coaster cars move from position 1 to position 2, they descend, resulting in a decrease in gravitational potential energy due to their lower height. However, their total energy—comprising both kinetic and potential energy—remains constant, assuming negligible friction. Option B incorrectly suggests that kinetic energy increases while gravitational potential energy decreases, but it does not address total energy. Option C misrepresents the relationship by stating total energy changes, which it does not. Option D also fails, as it inaccurately implies that gravitational potential energy is the only energy type being discussed.
As the roller coaster cars move from position 1 to position 2, they descend, resulting in a decrease in gravitational potential energy due to their lower height. However, their total energy—comprising both kinetic and potential energy—remains constant, assuming negligible friction. Option B incorrectly suggests that kinetic energy increases while gravitational potential energy decreases, but it does not address total energy. Option C misrepresents the relationship by stating total energy changes, which it does not. Option D also fails, as it inaccurately implies that gravitational potential energy is the only energy type being discussed.
Placing solid ammonium nitrate, NH4NO3, in a container of water causes an endothermic reaction. The result is ammonium hydroxide, NH4OH, and nitric acid, HNO3. Which diagram shows the correct equation for the reaction?
- A. NH4OH + HNO3 → NH4NO3 + H2O + energy
- B. NH4NO3 + H2O + energy → NH4OH + HNO3
- C. NH4NO3 + H2O → NH4OH + HNO3 + energy
- D. NH4OH + HNO3 + energy → NH4NO3 + H2O
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: B
The reaction involving solid ammonium nitrate and water is endothermic, meaning it absorbs energy. Option B accurately reflects this by showing ammonium nitrate and water reacting to form ammonium hydroxide and nitric acid while requiring energy input, consistent with the endothermic nature of the process. Option A incorrectly suggests that energy is released, which contradicts the reaction's endothermic characteristic. Option C also misrepresents the energy aspect, implying that energy is produced, which is not the case. Option D similarly indicates that energy is released, misaligning with the reaction's true nature.
The reaction involving solid ammonium nitrate and water is endothermic, meaning it absorbs energy. Option B accurately reflects this by showing ammonium nitrate and water reacting to form ammonium hydroxide and nitric acid while requiring energy input, consistent with the endothermic nature of the process. Option A incorrectly suggests that energy is released, which contradicts the reaction's endothermic characteristic. Option C also misrepresents the energy aspect, implying that energy is produced, which is not the case. Option D similarly indicates that energy is released, misaligning with the reaction's true nature.
Which statement is a valid conclusion from the data?
- A. The male athletes used more energy than the female athletes after 30 minutes of exercise.
- B. Strenuous exercise is more difficult for male athletes than female athletes.
- C. The average increase in heart rate was lower for the females than for the males.
- D. All the females had a lower heart rate than the males after 30 minutes of exercise.
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: C
Option C accurately reflects the data, indicating a measurable difference in heart rate between male and female athletes after 30 minutes of exercise. This conclusion is supported by the data trends, which typically show a higher average heart rate in males. Option A makes an assumption about energy expenditure without specific data to support it, making it invalid. Option B incorrectly suggests a subjective comparison of difficulty, which cannot be deduced from heart rate data alone. Lastly, Option D overgeneralizes by claiming that all females had lower heart rates than males, which is unlikely and not supported by typical statistical findings, as individual variations exist.
Option C accurately reflects the data, indicating a measurable difference in heart rate between male and female athletes after 30 minutes of exercise. This conclusion is supported by the data trends, which typically show a higher average heart rate in males. Option A makes an assumption about energy expenditure without specific data to support it, making it invalid. Option B incorrectly suggests a subjective comparison of difficulty, which cannot be deduced from heart rate data alone. Lastly, Option D overgeneralizes by claiming that all females had lower heart rates than males, which is unlikely and not supported by typical statistical findings, as individual variations exist.
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer:
Certainly! Please provide the question and the options so I can create the rationale for you.
Certainly! Please provide the question and the options so I can create the rationale for you.